Well this story started a few years ago when I brought the black gear gaiter, from ebay, which was purchased as a 5 speed one. This was to complete the black interior that I wanted to change my car to.
So finally, I got around to changing all the inside and put the gaiter on to find that it fitted all OK, but I could not get the ones towards the breaks in correct (2 & 4). I tried moving the surround down, but this did nothing.
I hunted down the old Tan one and looked at them together. No wonder the gears do not go in with the new black one on. It must be a 4 speed...